Day: April 22, 2019

Okhla waste-to-energy plant gets Centre’s notice over violations

By Shashikant Nishant Sharma

Consequently, the Union Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change (MoEF&CC) has issued a notice to the operator of the Okhla waste-to-energy (WTE) plant in southeast Delhi, requesting an explanation as to why the Environmental Clearance (EC) granted in 2007 should not be temporarily suspended. The notice, dated April 16 and signed by S Kerketta, director with the MoEF, invokes the powers vested under Section 5 of the Environment Protection Act, 1986, directing the company, M/s Timarpur Okhla Waste Management Company Pvt Ltd, to provide a response within 15 days. The EC is a prerequisite for the operation of a WTE plant.

The issuance of the notice follows a thorough inspection of the Okhla plant on December 15, 2018, which revealed numerous violations of the granted EC. The inspection team, led by Navin Chandra, chairman of the Expert Appraisal Committees (EAC), Thermal Power Projects, was formed by the MoEF in November 2018.

Citing non-compliance with the terms and conditions of the Environmental Clearance, the MoEF notice highlights concerns such as an increase in waste input, a rise in installed power generation, unauthorized construction of a new chimney, failure to establish a bio-methanation plant at Okhla, and the absence of an RDF plant at Timarpur.

The report submitted by the inspection team raised further issues, including overloading of municipal solid waste to the incinerators, the non-existence of the proposed bio-methanation plant at Okhla, and the failure to install a waste processing unit to generate RDF fluff at Timarpur. Additionally, the report noted deviations such as the installation of two stacks of 50 m height instead of the sanctioned single stack/chimney of 60 m height and the incomplete closure of waste storage pit gates, causing odour leakage in the area.

The Okhla WTE plant, serving areas under the jurisdiction of the South Delhi Municipal Corporation (SDMC) and the New Delhi Municipal Council (NDMC), has faced prolonged protests from locals due to alleged emissions violations and environmental pollution. Despite these concerns, the general manager of the Okhla plant, Sandip Dutt, claims that operations are in compliance, stating that they have not received any letter from the MoEF.

The notice reflects the acknowledgment of long-standing concerns by residents, as evidenced by a rally on March 24, where around 3,000 residents demanded the shutdown of the plant, emphasizing its proximity to habitation. Vinayak Malik, secretary of Sukhdev Vihar Welfare Association, asserts that the deviations mentioned in the MoEF notice align with the grievances raised by the local community over an extended period.

Okhla waste-to-energy plant gets Centre’s notice over violations

 The Union Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change (MoEF&CC) has sent a show-cause notice to the company running the Okhla waste-to-energy (WTE) plant in southeast Delhi, asking it to explain “why its Environmental Clearance (EC) granted in 2007 should not be kept in abeyance”.

Introduction

The Okhla Waste-to-Energy (WtE) plant is one of the prominent waste management facilities in India, located in the Okhla area of South Delhi. As urbanization continues to grow in cities like Delhi, managing municipal solid waste (MSW) has become a significant challenge. The Okhla WtE plant plays a crucial role in addressing this challenge by converting waste into energy, thus reducing the environmental impact of waste disposal and contributing to sustainable urban development.

Background and Establishment

The Okhla Waste-to-Energy plant was commissioned in 2012 and is operated by the Jindal Ecopolis, a subsidiary of Jindal Steel and Power Ltd. The plant was established under a Public-Private Partnership (PPP) model with the Delhi government, the Municipal Corporation of Delhi (MCD), and Jindal Ecopolis as stakeholders. The facility was built to address the growing issue of waste accumulation in Delhi and to generate electricity from waste, a renewable energy source.

Capacity and Operations

The Okhla WtE plant has a processing capacity of approximately 2,000 metric tons of municipal solid waste per day. It generates around 16 megawatts (MW) of electricity, which is supplied to the local grid, providing power to thousands of households in the area.

The plant uses incineration technology to burn the waste, producing heat that is used to generate steam. The steam drives turbines to produce electricity. The facility primarily handles mixed municipal waste, including biodegradable and non-biodegradable materials.

Key Features of the Plant

  1. Incineration Technology: The plant uses mass-burn incineration technology, where waste is burned at high temperatures in a controlled environment. This process significantly reduces the volume of waste, converting it into ash, flue gases, and heat energy. The heat energy is then used to generate electricity.

  2. Environmental Controls: The Okhla WtE plant is equipped with various environmental control systems to minimize emissions and pollutants. These include flue gas cleaning systems, electrostatic precipitators, and continuous emission monitoring systems (CEMS) to ensure that emissions meet regulatory standards. The plant is also designed to handle hazardous waste, ensuring that harmful substances are properly treated.

  3. Resource Recovery: In addition to generating electricity, the plant recovers materials like metals from the waste before incineration, contributing to resource conservation and reducing the need for raw materials.

  4. Waste Diversion: By converting waste into energy, the Okhla WtE plant helps divert a significant amount of waste from landfills, reducing the burden on the city’s waste disposal infrastructure.

Environmental Impact and Concerns

While the Okhla WtE plant contributes to waste management and renewable energy generation, it has also been the subject of environmental and health concerns. Local residents and environmental groups have raised concerns about air pollution, especially emissions of particulate matter, dioxins, and furans, which are harmful to human health and the environment.

  1. Air Quality Concerns: Critics argue that despite the plant’s emission control systems, it may still release pollutants that can contribute to air pollution in Delhi, a city already grappling with severe air quality issues. Studies and reports have highlighted the potential health risks associated with living near WtE plants, particularly for vulnerable populations.

  2. Health Impacts: Local communities have reported respiratory problems, skin conditions, and other health issues that they believe are linked to the plant’s emissions. The proximity of the plant to residential areas and hospitals has intensified these concerns.

  3. Regulatory Compliance: The plant has faced legal challenges and protests from environmental activists and local residents. In response, the operators have made efforts to improve emission controls and comply with environmental regulations. However, debates continue about whether the plant’s operations are fully aligned with the best practices for waste-to-energy technology.

  4. Alternatives to Incineration: Environmentalists advocate for more sustainable waste management practices, such as recycling, composting, and reducing waste generation at the source, rather than relying on incineration. They argue that WtE plants may undermine efforts to promote waste reduction and recycling by prioritizing waste as a fuel source.

Economic and Social Impact

  1. Economic Benefits: The Okhla WtE plant contributes to the local economy by generating electricity from waste, reducing dependence on fossil fuels, and creating jobs in waste management and plant operations. The PPP model has also encouraged private sector investment in waste management infrastructure.

  2. Social Impact: The plant has generated both positive and negative social impacts. While it provides electricity and reduces waste accumulation, it has also sparked concerns among local communities about health and environmental justice. The plant’s location in a densely populated urban area has led to debates about the equitable distribution of environmental risks and benefits.

  3. Public Awareness: The controversy surrounding the Okhla WtE plant has raised public awareness about waste management and environmental issues in Delhi. It has also sparked discussions about the need for more sustainable and community-friendly approaches to waste disposal.

Future Prospects and Sustainability

The future of the Okhla Waste-to-Energy plant lies in balancing the benefits of waste-to-energy technology with the need for environmental protection and public health. Potential improvements could include:

  1. Upgrading Technology: Investing in advanced incineration technology and more effective emission controls to further reduce the environmental impact of the plant.

  2. Promoting Waste Segregation: Encouraging better waste segregation at the source to improve the quality of waste fed into the plant and reduce the production of harmful emissions.

  3. Community Engagement: Strengthening dialogue with local communities and addressing their concerns through transparent monitoring and reporting of emissions and health impacts.

  4. Exploring Alternatives: Exploring alternative waste management strategies, such as anaerobic digestion, mechanical-biological treatment (MBT), and expanding recycling programs, to complement the WtE approach.

Conclusion

The Okhla Waste-to-Energy plant is a significant component of Delhi’s waste management strategy, providing a solution to the city’s growing waste disposal challenges while generating renewable energy. However, its environmental and health impacts have sparked ongoing debates about the best ways to manage urban waste sustainably. Balancing the plant’s benefits with the need for public health and environmental protection will be crucial in shaping the future of waste management in Delhi and other rapidly urbanizing cities.